Is Central Florida Still Smart for Investment Property in 2026?
I get this question more than almost any other: is Central Florida still a smart place to buy an investment property in 2026?
The honest answer is that it depends entirely on which of our two rental markets you mean — because they are currently moving in opposite directions.
The long-term rental market is cooling
Orlando's median asking rent for smaller units came in around $1,650, and it is down about 1.8% year over year. After the run-up we had coming out of the pandemic, rents are giving a little back. That does not make long-term rentals a bad idea — but it does mean you can no longer buy on the assumption that next year's rent covers this year's mistake. The numbers have to work on day one.
The short-term rental market is a different animal entirely
Down in the Kissimmee and Davenport corridor, close to the parks, the picture looks nothing like that. There are roughly 8,881 active short-term rental listings in the Kissimmee market. Occupancy is running about 57%, which is actually ahead of the Florida state average of 54%. Average daily rate sits near $192.
The average property there grosses about $36,838 a year.
And here is the number almost nobody quotes you.
Size is doing most of the work
Properties with six or more bedrooms average roughly $62,385 a year — about 70% more than the market average, in the same market, under the same rules, with the same management headaches.
That is the single most important thing to understand before you buy near the parks. A family of eight flying into Orlando is not choosing between your three-bedroom and a hotel. They are choosing between your seven-bedroom and somebody else's seven-bedroom. The large-home segment has genuinely different demand from the rest of the market, and the revenue reflects it.
Seasonality is real, and it will test you
March averages about $5,220 in monthly revenue. September averages about $1,378. That is not a rounding error — that is a four-to-one swing, and it is the reason under-capitalised short-term rental owners get into trouble. You are not running a business that earns evenly across twelve months. You are running one that earns most of its money in a handful of them and has to survive the rest.
Budget for the September version of your property, not the March version.
What financing looks like right now
Freddie Mac put the 30-year fixed at 6.69% this week, essentially flat from last week and within a few basis points of a year ago. Investment property financing typically prices above that, and most lenders will want more down. The upside is that rates have stopped whipsawing — the payment you underwrite today is likely close to the payment you actually get, which makes it possible to model a deal honestly again.
So — is it still smart?
Yes, with conditions. Long-term rentals work if you buy right and do not need appreciation to bail you out. Short-term rentals work if you buy big enough and capitalise for the off-season. What does not work in 2026 is buying an average property in an average location and assuming the market carries you. That market ended a while ago.
Before you shop, know exactly what you can borrow and on what terms. It changes which of these two strategies is even available to you.
If you want me to run the actual numbers on a specific proper
ty — long-term rent comps, short-term revenue estimates, or both side by side — reach out. I will tell you honestly if a deal does not work.
Troy Boss, REALTOR® · LIFESTYLE International Realty · (315) 335-4622
Have a great day — and remember, don't gamble with your biggest investment. Call the Boss!
Data: Rabbu Kissimmee short-term rental market report (April 2026); Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (August 6, 2026); Orlando rent trend reporting (Ackley Florida). Figures are market averages and are not a projection for any specific property.
Recent Posts
"My job is to find and attract mastery-based agents to the office, protect the culture, and make sure everyone is happy! "